Across the global dairy processing industry, a startling efficiency gap has emerged. Benchmarking studies from Forbes Marshall reveal that some dairy plants consume up to three times more energy per gallon of milk processed than others, despite producing similar products at a comparable scale. This discrepancy is not a matter of geography or capacity, but rather how effectively a plant manages its most critical utility: steam.
With raw milk accounting for approximately 70% of total production costs, utility efficiency stands as the single largest controllable lever for improving a dairy’s profitability. Mastering the steam system is the fastest, most impactful method for processors to lower operational costs, meet aggressive sustainability targets, and sharpen their competitive edge.
The 20% Opportunity: A Holistic Approach
Industry data suggests that by addressing common efficiency gaps, dairy processors can reduce fuel consumption by roughly 20%. This is achieved through a holistic three-pillar strategy: generating steam efficiently, using it effectively within the process, and recovering every possible drop of energy.
Optimizing the Source: The Boiler Room as a Profit Center
Efficiency begins in the boiler room, where systems should ideally operate at close to 90% efficiency. However, fluctuating loads and poor combustion often secretly downgrade performance. To transform the boiler room into a profit center, Forbes Marshall recommends focusing on four key metrics:
- Steam-to-Fuel Ratio: Maintain a ratio of approximately 85 Lbs/Therm.
- Oxygen (O2) Levels: Keep levels stable between 3–4%.
- Feedwater Temperature: Ensure temperatures are near 212°F without the use of live steam injection.
- Automated Blowdown: Control Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) to prevent scaling and equipment-damaging carryover.
Furthermore, a common industry mistake is operating boilers at low pressure. Distributing steam at the boiler's rated pressure reduces the specific volume of the steam, allowing for smaller pipelines that lower both CAPEX and OPEX. Reducing pressure only at the point of use improves the dryness fraction and raises available heat.
Eliminating Inefficiencies in Core Dairy Processes
The article highlights four critical areas where steam mismanagement leads to significant production losses:
- Pasteurizers: Solving the "Stall" Phenomenon
Inconsistent temperatures during pasteurization (typically at ~172°F) frequently trigger flow diversion valves (FDV), forcing costly product reprocessing. This is often caused by "stall"—where upstream pressure drops below downstream pressure, preventing condensate removal.
The Solution: Utilizing steam-operated pump traps and optimized supply maintains uniform temperatures and can increase milk processed per unit of steam by 10–12%.
Case Study: One dairy reduced FDV opening incidences from 20 per day to just one, while increasing milk processed from 3.5 to 6.2 gallons per pound of steam. - Multiple Effect Evaporators (MEEs): Maximizing Throughput
MEEs are essential for concentrating milk solids, but conventional control philosophies often fail to adapt to real-world variations in milk flow and vacuum levels.
The Solution: A control philosophy that manages steam flow for each feed range and maintains vapor balance can achieve 15–20% higher steam economy and more consistent outlet concentrations. - Spray Driers: Achieving Uniform Moisture
Fluctuating hot air temperatures often lead to clumping or reduced product weight in spray drying. These inconsistencies are primarily due to incorrect steam trap selection and "group trapping," which hinders heat transfer.
The Solution: Individual trapping for each radiator cassette and flash steam recovery can stabilize air temperatures.
Case Study: A 40,000 Lbs/day spray dryer saved 1,206 Lbs/hour of steam and 72 gallons/hour of water by introducing individual trapping and reusing flash steam. - Clean-In-Place (CIP): Faster Cycles, Less Waste
Many dairies struggle with prolonged CIP start-up times despite high steam supply.
The Solution: Reducing steam pressure to below 30 PSIg and integrating precise controls can eliminate stall, delivering 5–7% steam savings and faster turnaround times without compromising sanitation protocols.
From Data to Dominance
The greatest operational gains are realized when processors view their steam and process systems as a single, integrated ecosystem. While digital tools provide essential visibility into boiler and trap performance, data is only the starting point. The ultimate goal is to use that data to drive targeted, holistic actions that transform plant performance.
For dairy processors, mastering the steam system is no longer just a maintenance task—it is a long-term competitive advantage in an increasingly tight market.
Explore More:
To learn how to pinpoint inefficiencies and implement holistic steam solutions in your facility, visit our specialized dairy industry resource page or email us at [email protected]
Since 1946, Forbes Marshall has provided innovative solutions to help businesses globally improve their process and energy efficiency and be more environmentally responsible. We specialize in products and services for steam efficiency, process optimization, and control and monitoring. Our digital offerings go beyond connectivity and help measure, analyze and sustain their key performance indicators. This helps optimize output and yield quality while keeping the energy and resource consumption measurably low. Forbes Marshall Inc. has been serving process industries across the USA for over 27 years.
Forbes Marshall is on LinkedIn and YouTube.